Overprotective mom wants to cut down all trees to keep her kids from possible allergies

It's one thing to be a protective mother. That's actually something I can understand. I mean, who doesn't want to have their kid's best interests at heart? One mom, though, is taking things WAY too far. A mom in Vaughan, Canada, is asking the city to cut down all oak trees near an elementary school because she's afraid that the fallen acorns are going to cause an allergic reaction in one of the kids. The only caveat in her worries? The kids aren't actually being forced to EAT the nuts, since the school itself is a nut-free zone.


Read more in ¿Qué más? Baby girls exposed to stress could be prone to anxiety in their teen years

Donna Giustizia is the chair of St. Stephen Catholic Elementary School's allergy committee and worried about how the trees on the property are littering the area with acorns. She claims that it's giving allergic kids "a false sense of security" to put a "sign on the door that says nut-free and there's nuts all over the place".

Well, that would be a very good point--except that there's no proof that fallen acorns could cause an allergic reaction unless they're eaten. Dr. Paul Keith tells The Star that "the only situation I could see is if they were bullied and forced to eat them, you really have to eat them to have a reaction." Meanwhile, Dr. Maria Asper said that skin contact COULD cause a local reaction like redness or hives but she's "not aware of any reports of children having an anaphylactic reaction upon contact with acorns. For the most part, as long as they're just handled and not ingested, there's no scientific literature to suggest anyone has had a reaction."

Read more in ¿Qué más? Dad who used dog to pull out daughter's loose tooth is so not funny! (VIDEO)

Honestly, I think this mom is just overreacting to the whole thing. Are we seriously going to cut down trees that aren't actually harming anyone just because we're a little afraid that a kid might pick up an acorn and have an allergic reaction? From the sounds of it, that isn't even possible unless he eats it! Seriously, the school is nut-free so long as they're not serving nuts in any of their dishes. But abusing the natural wildlife to protect your kids from something that they don't even need protection from? Well, that's just crazy and going WAY too far in my book.

Image via Thinkstock

Do you think that the city should cut down the acorn trees in case kids have an allergic reaction?

Topics: back to school  parenting fail  allergies  overprotective


Do you think that the city should cut down the acorn trees in case kids have an allergic reaction?

nonmember avatar
on Nov 15, 2012 at 7:44 AM
his is total craziness! I have a severe dairy allergy, not lactosis intollerance, but a severy allergyl.... I grew up and could not eat baby food unless homemade no additatives, could not drink milk except goat milk (and two of my three children are they same) could not breast feed as they did not know what was wrong with me. My mother and father just TAUGHT me that I could NOT drink milk, or eat anything with milk...it was NOT banned from my school or from our church, or my friends. This is Just goving overboard. Granted I understand that a peanut allergy can just be inhaled, and not even eaten. A milk allergy probably won't kill me, however it makes me very, very, very ill for several days when I have eaten it and did not know...but that is NOT anyone's problem but mine and I have to ask about cheese, gravy, and addivatives, especially eating out. Denise Fencl, Elkhorn, NE
Report this comment
on Apr 25, 2015 at 3:49 AM

When we decided to broaden the pathway which connects the main road to my home, I had to call the professional tree cutters who were just one call away, so they helped me to clear the space before laying down the paver stones.

Report this comment
1-3 of 3
To leave a comment on this story, please log in with:
  • Facebook
  • MamásLatinas
  • Comment as a Guest
you are logged in as (logout)
Submitting comment, please wait...